Crispy Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwich – 3 Ways

Ah, the almighty crispy spicy fried chicken sandwich! My crispy spicy fried chicken sandwich is marinated in a spicy buttermilk batter, dredged in seasoned flour and fried to a beautiful crisp. This recipe will show you how to prepare this crsipy, spicy fried chicken sandwich three different ways. Choose from buttermilk-ranch style, hot honey style or honey-lime chipotle!

Oh, and take your pick of several delicious toppings: sweet and tangy coleslaw, kosher dill pickles or crispy onion strings! I curate three distinct styles of this crispy spicy fried chicken sandwich in this post. These are just recommendations! Feel free to switch them up!

Thighs or breasts for a fried chicken sandwich?

The consensus all across the internet suggest that thighs make better sandwiches than breasts. I’m not sure I agree that one is better than the other. It really depends on whether you prefer white meat (breasts) or dark meat (thighs).

My preference is less fatty, white meat, so I favor breasts. Chicken thighs have a few advantages though. First, they’re fattier which makes them juicier, and they fit on the bun better.

Chicken breast can be halved to make the perfect bun-sized breasts. Stay away from thin-sliced breasts and try to find breasts that are about 1 inch thick! Any thicker than this and they could take a long time to cook.

I strongly suggest using a meat thermometer to get an accurate internal-temperature reading. Breasts need to be cooked to an internal temperature of 160 degrees (fahrenheit), and thighs need to reach an internal temperature of 165 degrees.

Decisions, decisions…

By nature, I’m an indecisive person. Of course I can’t commit to one way of dressing these little ladies up. And I don’t expect you to either! That’s why I created three crispy spicy fried chicken sandwiches! The crispy spicy coating and buttery brioche buns are a constant for all three sandwiches, they’re just dressed up differently.

Crispy Buttermilk-Ranch Chicken Sandwich

There’s nothing better than some buttermilk-ranch to cool down spicy chicken! Throw a few kosher pickle chips on there and some shredded iceberg and you get this beauty!

Buttermilk-Ranch Dressing

Look at the way that ranch just drips down! That’s because my homemade-ranch dressing is mainly buttermilk-based. I mix equal parts buttermilk and sour cream with a little mayo, a splash of apple cider vinegar, a squeeze of lemon and lots of fresh dill and chives. The key is to go easy on the mayo! I have yet to find a bottled ranch that doesn’t taste mayonnaise-y, so that’s why I set out to create my own,

Honey-Lime Chipotle Chicken Sandwich

Now this one is definitely the most work out of the three but every bit worth it! We are pulling out all the stops! This crsipy, spicy fried chicken sandwich is dressed with honey-lime chipotle mayo, sweet and tangy coleslaw and crispy fried onion strings!

Honey-lime chipotle mayo

This honey-lime chipotle mayo is spicy, sweet and tangy. It is frigging delicious y’all! It gets its spiciness from adobo-soaked chipotle peppers, its sweetness from honey, and the tanginess from lime juice. You could even leave off the coleslaw and fried onions, slap some sauce on there with some pickles, and this spicy fried chicken sandwich will still be slammin’.

Crispy Spicy Hot-Honey Chicken Sandwich

Choosing a favorite between these 3 Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwiches is like asking me to pick a favorite child. Not happening. But I think I’m ok with calling this one my baby.

Do I double-stack it in real life? No, but doesn’t it look amazing? Spicy chicken smothered in hot honey and lots of pickles! Yes. Please.

Spicy Hot Honey

It really doesn’t get any more simple than this delicious hot-honey. Don’t let its simplicity fool you though. This hot-honey will knock your socks off! It’s made of equal parts honey and Lousiana-style hot sauce with a few drops of lime juice and a dash of smoked paprika. Easy peasy.

Just a few things before you get started:

1. Don’t rush the marinating process! The crispy spicy fried chicken gets its tenderness and its kick from being soaked in buttermilk and hot sauce. I threw some ground mustard into the marinade to give it some tang. It needs to marinate for 1-4 hours in the refrigerator.
2. Don’t skimp on the seasonings either! The seasoned flour adds a second layer of spice to the crispy spicy fried chicken. You need to season the buttermilk marinade and the flour!
3. Invest in a reliable meat thermometer. There shouldn’t be any guesswork in cooking chicken all the way through! Chicken thighs should cook for about 15-18 minutes and reach an internal temperature of 165 degrees F. Breasts need to be cooked to 160 degrees F.
4. Check the temperature of your oil! Your oil should be 350 degrees fahrenheit before dropping the chicken in.
5. Butter your buns! Nobody likes dry buns! I like to brush the split-side of my brioche buns with butter and heat them on the griddle (just until warm) for a few minutes, before assembling the sandwiches.
6. Not all pickles are created equal! Splurge on some good ones and skip the generic ones!
7. Switch it up! Don’t care for onion strings or coleslaw? Want to combine the honey-lime chipotle mayo with pickles instead? No problem! Create your own combination and let me know in the comments how it turned out!

Which one is your favorite?

Recipe Rating